Results for Immunity Challenge #12


TREE MAIL


"Friendly Fire"

This challenge is very simple. Each player was given 5 lit torches, each one below a bucket of water. When it's their turn, they will fire an antique pirate cannon at the buckets above the other players' torches. If they successfully knock over the bucket, it will put out the torch below it. When their last torch has been extinguished, they are immediately out of the challenge. The last player remaining with at least one lit torch remaining wins Immunity from Tribal Council. If there is a pecking order, this challenge will definitely reveal it!

There is a twist, however... Only 12 of the torches are labelled with the players' names. The rest are blank. Who each of these blank torches belong to not revealed while the contestants were making their choices. They are based on submitted page timers, so there IS a chance of dousing one of their own torches! Blank torches marked with a "#1" will be for the player submitted with the shortest page timer, "#2" for the 2nd shortest, and so on... They have no way of predicting which mystery torch was theirs.

The order the players take their turn is the order in which the players submitted the challenge. Take a look below.


Challenge Results

This is the order in which the players submitted their choices,
and the amount of time each player spent on the challenge page.

This decides the order the players get to fire the cannon, and which mystery torches belong to them.

Player:
Johnny
Brentin
Jessie
K.J.
Submission
Order:
1st
2nd
3rd
4th
Page Timer:
1min
58sec
8min
30sec
1min
8sec
1min
12sec
Mystery
Torches:
# 3
# 4
# 1
# 2



Now, let's see how this plays out.

Here are the torches:



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 










Brentin
Jessie
Johnny
K.J.
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 











Johnny
K.J.
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
Johnny
K.J.




1st Round

1) Johnny shoots at K.J.'s torch, and it's a hit!
2) Brentin shoots at Johnny's torch, and it's a hit!
3) Jessie shoots at K.J.'s torch, and it's a hit!
4) K.J. shoots at Johnny's torch, and it's a hit!



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 










Brentin
Jessie
Johnny
K.J.
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 











Johnny
K.J.
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
Johnny
K.J.




2nd Round

1) Johnny shoots at Mystery Torch #2 (belonging to K.J.), and it's a hit!
2) Brentin shoots at K.J.'s torch, and it's a hit!
3) Jessie shoots at Mystery Torch #1 (oops, it's her own), and it's a hit!
4) K.J. shoots at another one of Johnny's torches, and it's another hit!



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 










Brentin
Jessie
Johnny
K.J.
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 











Johnny
K.J.
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
Johnny
K.J.




Let's condense to one row for the 3rd Round

1) Johnny shoots at Mystery Torch #3 (oops, it's his own), and it's a hit!
2) Brentin shoots at Johnny's torch, and it's a MISS! Johnny has no remaining visibile torches.
3) Jessie shoots at Mystery Torch #4 (belonging to Brentin), and it's a hit!
4) K.J. also shoots at Johnny's torch, and it's a MISS! Johnny has no remaining visibile torches.



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 













Brentin
Jessie
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie



4th Round

1) Johnny shoots at Jessie's torch, and it's a hit!
2) Brentin shoots at Johnny's torch again, and it's a MISS! Johnny has no remaining visibile torches.
3) Jessie shoots at Mystery Torch #3 (belonging to Johnny), and it's a hit, taking Johnny out of the game!

4) K.J. shoots at Mystery Torch #1 (belonging to Jessie), and it's a hit!



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 













Brentin
Jessie
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie



5th Round

1) Brentin shoots at Mystery Torch #1, and it's a MISS!! Jessie has no remaining Mystery Torches.
2) Jessie shoots at Johnny's torch, and it's a MISS! Johnny is already out of the game.
3) K.J. shoots at Mystery Torch #2 (oops, it's her own), and it's a hit, taking herself out of the game!



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 













Brentin
Jessie
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie



6th Round

1) Brentin shoots at Mystery Torch #2, and it's a MISS! K.J. is already out of the game.
2) Jessie shoots at K.J.'s torch, and it's a MISS! K.J. is already out of the game.


7th Round

1) Brentin shoots at Mystery Torch #3, and it's a MISS! Johnny is already out of the game.
2) Jessie shoots at K.J.'s torch again, and it's a MISS! K.J. is already out of the game.


8th Round

1) Brentin shoots at Mystery Torch #4 (oops, it's his own), and it's a hit!
2) Jessie shoots at Johnny's torch, and it's a MISS! Johnny is already out of the game.



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 













Brentin
Jessie
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie


9th Round

1) Brentin shoots at K.J.'s torch, and it's a MISS! K.J. is already out of the game.
2) Jessie shoots at Johnny's torch again, and it's a MISS! Johnny is already out of the game.


10th Round

1) Brentin shoots at K.J.'s torch again, and it's a MISS! K.J. is already out of the game.
2) Jessie shoots at Brentin's torch, and it's a hit!



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 













Brentin
Jessie
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie


11th Round

1) Brentin shoots at Jessie's torch, and it's a hit!
2) Jessie shoots at Brentin's torch again, and it's a hit!



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 













Brentin
Jessie
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie


CURRENT STANDINGS

We are left with Brentin and Jessie, each having only one visible torch remaining.
If either player chooses the other this round, the challenge is over and we have a winner!


Let's continue...


12th Round

1) Brentin shoots at Jessie's torch again, and it's a hit, taking Jessie out of the game!
Jessie's 12th move actually WAS for Brentin, but because Brentin's turn comes first, Jessie does not get to make her move. Brentin is the winner with only ONE torch remaining!



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 













Brentin
Jessie
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie


We have a winner!

Jessie's 12th move actually WAS for Brentin, but because Brentin's turn comes first, Jessie does not get to make her move. Brentin is the winner with only ONE torch remaining!



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 













Brentin
Jessie
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie
??? #1
??? #2
??? #3
??? #4
Brentin
Jessie

 


Challenge Summary

Brentin wins Immunity! This is the first time Brentin has won individual Immunity.

Congrats, Brentin! You are safe at Tribal Council!


Balboa Tribe, head back to camp.
I'll notify you when it's time to go to Tribal Council.

 

CBS.com
Show | Survivors | Challenges | Tribal Council | Calendar | Feedback | Player Login | FAQ | Host | Archives | Application
Virtual Survivor and VirtualSurvivor.net are not affiliated with or endorsed by CBS, DJB, SEG, or Survivor Productions LLC
Tribal Council, Challenge, and Poll form submissions courtesy of OneGuy.com
Original Content ©2000-2008 by Virtual Survivor and VirtualSurvivor.net